The problem with the US surrogacy system

For some couples, surrogacy is a miracle: an opportunity to have a child even if they’re unable to conceive one naturally.

But it’s also big business.

Not only is surrogacy expensive — think six figures — but it’s also largely unregulated.

And that last part is becoming a bigger problem.

Just last week, a California couple was arrested on child abuse charges after it was revealed that they had over 20 children from different surrogate mothers living in a large mansion in Arcadia, a city near Los Angeles.

Many of the surrogates are currently fighting for custody through the courts of the children they carried.

The Arcadia case, however, is only the most recent example of how surrogacy can go wrong.

Every case is different, but every one illuminates how opaque — and often ripe for abuse or legal issues — the American surrogacy industry is.

Emi Nietfeld is a reporter at Washington Sun who writes about surrogacy, IVF, and how we build families.

She spoke with Today, Explained co-host Noel King about what’s kept lawmakers from regulating the surrogacy industry, the recent high-profile cases bringing these problems to light, and why more regulation doesn’t necessarily offer a straightforward fix.

Below is an excerpt of their conversation, edited for length and clarity.

There’s much more in the full podcast, so listen to Today, Explained wherever you get podcasts, including Apple Podcasts , Pandora , and Spotify .

The United States does not regulate the surrogacy industry seemingly at all.

What is going on? Why not? The lack of federal regulation is both political and financial.